A Precious Gift- Fresh From Nantucket: Bay Scallops!

Monahan's Seafood Market | Fresh Whole Fish, Fillets, Shellfish, Recipes, Catering & Lunch Counter-Ann Arbor, Michigan

Every year, at the beginning of October, family fishing season starts for the locals on Nantucket Island for one of the sea’s greatest treasures- bay scallops! Locals are allowed to catch 1 bushel per week all month, then in early November the commercial season begins and lasts until March. The bay scallop plays a big part in Nantucket’s culture. Everyone involved from the scallopers to the many shuckers (“openers”), retailers and wholesalers have a stake in this small and fickle fishery.

Bay scallop catches vary greatly from season to season. Back in 1980 when our market was just 1 year old, Nantucket had a banner catch of 120,000 bushels. Since then harvests have had ups and downs. 2007 reported 3,860 bushels, in 2008, 17,000 bushels then down to 6,916 bushels the following season. We got our first shipment of these beauties from Nantucket today!

The weather can affect the fishery greatly. Rough winter weather can make it tough on the scallopers to get on the water and if the temperature is below 28 degrees before 10 a.m. a red flag will go up at the harbormaster’s office to announce that “there’s no fishing today”. The reason for this rule is that young scallops (1 year or less) or babies (spats) will die when they hit air that’s that cold. No one knows for sure why there are such fluctuations in catches from season to season but the loss of eelgrass, the nursery area for young scallops, in some areas definitely has to be a factor. Predators such as crabs, starfish, conch and oyster drills eat a lot of bay scallops and there are other natural reasons like weather and water salinity.

The bay scallop fisheries in the Northeast, which includes Rhode Island, Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard and Long Island haven’t produced much in recent years. Nantucket’s catches have been down from historic highs also but still remain a viable scalloping culture supplying what many say are the finest scallops in the world. Their sweetness and buttery texture is unbelievable. Forget your Coquille St. Jaques or any other fancy recipe. These babies should be eaten raw, maybe with a squeeze of lemon or maybe in ceviche (lightly marinated), or quickly caramelized in a pan with a little butter.

Here are 2 of the easiest recipes you’ll ever make (and most delicious)!

Sautéed Nantucket Bay scallops and Mike Monahan’s Nantucket Bay scallop ceviche

Monahan's Seafood

4 Responses to “A Precious Gift- Fresh From Nantucket: Bay Scallops!

  • Hi there, I would like to subscribe for this blogs to get most recent updates, thus where can I do it. Please help out. Thank you!

    • Hi Shirley-
      I will be glad to add your email to our subscription. It can be done on our homepage as well. It is called the Friday Fish Report and comes to your inbox every Friday as well as being posted here.
      Thanks for your interest!

  • Wendy Williams
    2 years ago

    I love these substantive posts about the health of the fisheries and availability of such great seasonal stuff! Thanks so much for writing about it.

  • mm
    Monahan's Seafood
    2 years ago

    Thanks Wendy and thanks for reading!

Leave a Reply Text

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *